How and why have the narratives shifted?
1 min read
- View as Markdown Open this page as plain Markdown (opens in a new tab)
- Open in ChatGPT Ask questions about this page (opens in a new tab)
- Open in Claude Ask questions about this page (opens in a new tab)
- Open in Google AI Studio Ask questions about this page (Google account required) (opens in a new tab)
As the American Jewish community shifts in understanding the harms of Zionism and the past and present crimes of the Israeli state, public narratives are slowly shifting as well. Across national and local mainstream media, as well as in online discourse, the following narratives are now treated as fact:
- The American Jewish community is divided over Israel
- Anti-Zionist Jews are a significant part of the American Jewish community
- Many American Jews are sympathetic to Palestinian rights and want U.S. policy towards Israel to change
This shift in what the media covers and validates is vital. For decades, the dominant narrative was that all American Jews stood with Israel, which allowed mainstream media and elected officials to discount and ignore Jewish critique of the state of Israel, and also let them portray attempts to hold the Israeli state accountable as either “anti-Jewish” or only coming from “one side of the conflict.” But, every time the media has been forced to acknowledge Jewish opposition to the actions of the state of Israel and Jewish support for Palestinian rights, the very premise of that racist and deadly falsehood is further undermined. The destruction of that key piece of propaganda is a major reason why American popular opinion opposes giving more U.S. funding and weapons to Israel, and why American support for Palestine is at a record high.
This is huge, but it cannot be taken for granted. The Right is consolidating its control over all forms of media, and popular opinion does not move in a straight line. The coming years will require us to be more and more creative in telling our stories and defending these narrative shifts.