U.S.-Israel Alliance: Cultural
13 min read
- View as Markdown Open this page as plain Markdown (opens in a new tab)
- Open in ChatGPT Ask questions about this page (opens in a new tab)
- Open in Claude Ask questions about this page (opens in a new tab)
- Open in Google AI Studio Ask questions about this page (Google account required) (opens in a new tab)
Theory of Change #
Challenging the conflation of Judaism and Zionism and working to dismantle antisemitism and its weaponization is our responsibility as anti-Zionist Jews working toward Palestinian liberation. This work is what we have referred to as our cultural pillar, and at the same time, we know that conflation and weaponization acts as an attempted moral cover over the financial and political motivations underlying the relationship between the U.S. and Israeli states. For that reason, our work to shift culture is both its own pillar and an overall goal, filter and lens for all of our work in the family of organizations.
Over the past 2.5 years, we’ve helped create a sea change in popular understanding about the American Jewish community. That includes these narratives, which are now treated as common sense by the media and by elected officials: The American Jewish community is divided over Israel; Anti-Zionist Jews are a significant part of the American Jewish community; and many American Jews are sympathetic to Palestinian rights and want U.S. policy towards Israel to change. Maintaining this narrative shift is core to our work, as it opens key doors for — and removes massive blocks to — material, lasting change.
These narratives are now found everywhere, from the New York Times and the local evening news to podcasts, YouTubers and Tiktok videos. Over the past 2.5 years there were hundreds of stories featuring American Jewish families divided in their support for Israel, and dozens in which Jews talk about their journey to opposing Israel’s actions or even becoming anti-Zionist. There have also been many hundreds of Jews interviewed who identify, publicly and proudly, as anti-Zionist. And there were thousands of stories featuring American Jewish opposition to Israeli genocide, with hundreds acknowledging the 40% of Jews who support a weapons embargo.
This shift in what the media covers and validates is vital. For decades, the dominant narrative was that all American Jews stood with Israel, which allowed mainstream media and elected officials to discount and ignore Jewish critique of the state of Israel, and also let them portray attempts to hold the Israeli state accountable as either “anti-Jewish” or only coming from “one side of the conflict.”
Since 1967, the dominant narrative also dismissed anti-Zionist Jews as too small and too fringe — actively enabled by legacy Zionist Jewish institutions pushing anti-Zionists out of their spaces and erasing our anti-Zionist history. This allowed the media and elected officials to actively silence anti-Zionist voices (for instance, until 2023, the New York Times only used anti-Zionist as an insult). Most importantly, the Israeli government, and its supporters, has intentionally portrayed the ethnic cleansing and genocide of Palestinians as the “inevitable” result of an ancient, “existential conflict” between Jews and Arabs/Palestinians, a circular argument that pre-emptively justifies Israeli war crimes.
But, every time the media has been forced to acknowledge Jewish opposition to the actions of the state of Israel and Jewish support for Palestinian rights, the very premise of that racist and deadly falsehood is further undermined. The destruction of that key piece of propaganda is a major reason why American popular opinion opposes giving more U.S. funding and weapons to Israel, and why American support for Palestine is at a record high.
This is huge, but it cannot be taken for granted. The right is consolidating its control over all forms of media, and popular opinion does not move in a straight line. The coming years will require us to be more and more creative in telling our stories and defending these narrative shifts.
In response to these massive narrative gains, the Israeli and U.S. governments, supported by anti-Palestinian organizations, have ramped up concerted campaigns to re-define and mis-state the meaning of antisemitism, aiming to falsely conflate it with criticisms of the state of Israel or Zionism. They do this so the Israeli regime can maintain full impunity for ethnic cleansing, apartheid and genocide.
Combatting antisemitism — and its weaponization — has always been central to our mandate and mission, and it must remain so. Disrupting the narrative, legal and political weaponization of antisemitism is necessary to protect and advance all proactive strategies for justice led by the movement for Palestinian liberation.
False and distorted definitions of antisemitism also harm the fight against actual antisemitism, especially as white nationalism and white supremacy grow in the U.S. and around the world. The Trump administration uses animosity toward all who don’t fit into or help strengthen white Christian conservative “American” identities, mobilizing antisemitism, Islamophobia, anti-immigrant and anti-trans ideology to build and consolidate power for a fascist agenda. At the same time, the Trump regime weaponizes false claims of antisemitism to suppress free speech, restrict protest rights and normalize fascism.
How much of this is new? #
Intervening in the conflation of Judaism and Zionism and disrupting the weaponization of antisemitism is certainly not new. This work has been and will continue to be the centerpiece of our mandate. But as the terrain and texture of these fights shifts, JVP is shifting as well. A few key developments in the political context are refining JVP’s approach for the coming few years.
The biggest shift to this work is that the broad mainstream Zionist consensus in the U.S. public that has existed since 1967 is over. Rage at the state of Israel has grown broadly and rightfully, and with that opening, the right wing is advancing wrong and sometimes intentionally anti-Jewish explanations of how power functions.
It’s a critical moment to ensure a robust program of political education and media work that welcomes people’s rightful anger at the U.S.-Israel war machine while moving them into a grounded understanding of the structures that uphold it and what can be done to dismantle it. Within this political education work, we will also continue advancing concrete efforts to dismantle antisemitism in a framework of collective liberation.
Another part of the weakening consensus on Zionism is that the conflation of Jewishness with the Israeli state no longer works to hold back the pro-Palestine sentiments of the public. However, in response to this sea change of public opinion, Zionist organizations are now focused on codifying that false conflation into enforceable law.
Given this, JVP will need to continue to carry out disciplined, visible and strategic Jewish mobilizations that remain a hallmark of the massive narrative shift achieved during the last 2.5 years. In the coming years, as JVP orients towards running and winning materially impactful campaigns, it will remain a core goal to continue telling the story of Jewish opposition to Zionism in a coherent and clear way that sustains and deepens that narrative shift.
We’ve also sharpened our assessments of the most critical terrain for this struggle. College and university campuses are laboratories for anti-Palestinian policy under the guise of combatting antisemitism, and so we must sharpen our campus work, including using brand new strategies like affirmative litigation. We’ve also identified a critical need to intervene when Jewish religious and communal spaces are used to advance Zionist colonization, including hosting Israeli ethnic cleansing real estate events for selling land in illegal settlements exclusively to American Jews.
Finally, we’re sharpening our approach to contesting for power against Zionist legacy Jewish organizations, with a strong focus on where we can match our strengths to their weaknesses — especially at the local level — and where we are able to materially intervene against their marshalling of financial and political resources toward support of Israeli apartheid and genocide.
Priority Strategies #
We will continue to be a visible Jewish presence mobilizing for Palestine, particularly when the opportunities and conditions emerge to bring the fight for Palestine to the forefront of mass and mainstream consciousness. (See here for more details on mobilizing.) This includes continuing to flank Palestinian-led protests, as well as leading anti-Zionist Jewish protest. JVP-led protests, with our shirts, our banners and our song and prayer, have become recognized across the world as a model for matching visionary demands (in our case, grounded in Jewish social justice values) with common-sense demands for concrete policy change. The action logic is crystal clear and irrefutable. This helps ensure our demands resonate with a massive number of people, many outside the movement, while simultaneously offering the media an accessible and enticing story.
Goals:
- Help maintain our dominant narrative shifts by continuing to hold highly visible anti-Zionist protests with clear, compelling action logic
- Protect and support Palestinian-led protest, at times through visibly Jewish cohorts, and especially against attacks through weaponized antisemitism
We will continue to fight the distorted weaponization of antisemitism, used in public narratives and policy to maintain the genocide in Palestine and advance racist and authoritarian rule in the U.S., with sharpened analyses and tools.
Tactics include:
- Developing robust plans for toxifying IHRA and other forms of weaponized antisemitism on college and university campuses, including inside/outside game for campus administrators.
- With one of the best civil rights litigation firms on our team, it is our responsibility to take on a precedent-setting legal battle directly within our mandate and offer a robust legal challenge to the use of IHRA on campuses.
- Defensive campaigns (legislative and popular opinion) to combat the adoption of IHRA by federal, state, city and institutional policy makers.
- Educational and analysis-building trainings on fighting the weaponization of antisemitism.
- Action-oriented tools for chapters and pods to use in fighting the weaponization of antisemitism.
We will work to dismantle actual antisemitism at a time when explicit white nationalists run the country. This is a key part of our commitment to collective liberation.
Tactics include:
- Educational and analysis-building trainings, partnering with PARCEO in both communities and on campuses
- Building out guides and toolkits as action-oriented, one-stop tools that our chapters, pods and partners can use to offer teach-ins and take action against antisemitism
- Intervene in growing right-wing analyses of Zionism and the state of Israel that use incorrect and sometimes anti-Jewish power analyses
Example: Students at Northwestern led a boycott of a new, mandatory antisemitism training their university implemented as part of its deal with the Trump administration. The required training centered on Israel and compared the words of unnamed anti-Zionists to David Duke. In addition to the boycott campaign, students partnered with PARCEO to build understanding of what actual antisemitism is and how campuses can confront it through strategies of collective liberation.
We will weaken and challenge Jewish Zionist institutions by leveraging our strengths against their weaknesses, and focus our efforts where we can materially shift their impact. We will focus on two key areas: local movement defense work and national, focused and strategic campaigns.
Tactics:
- Defending local movement progress: JVP is particularly strong at countering anti-Palestinian Jewish institutions like the ADL, Hillel and Federations when we challenge them at the local, campus or state level where they are pushing dangerous policy or attempting to prevent or overturn movement victories. In these struggles, the focus remains on the material stakes and goals of the primary strategies — whether an Israel Bonds divestment push or an arms embargo bill — while exposing and challenging those organizations’ false claims to speak for Jews or against antisemitism.
- Member experience affirms this is the terrain where we can challenge these groups most effectively, as we often have greater numbers of organized Jews locally than they do and deeper partnerships, which we use to effectively thwart their attempts to weaponize antisemitism.
- Example: JVP-Bay Area ran a successful campaign for Alameda County’s divestment from companies profiting from genocide, resulting in immediate divestment from Caterpillar and a commitment to develop an Ethical Investment Policy that prohibits investment of taxpayer dollars in companies complicit in human rights abuses. For months, JVP-Bay Area members contacted and met with elected officials, wrote letters to the editor and made public comments in support of divestment as Jews for Palestinian freedom. In late 2024, during a meeting of the Alameda County Board of supervisors, one opponent of the proposed policy remarked how “few Jews” were present at the meeting. In response to his claim, dozens of JVP-BA chapter members and other Jews of conscience stood up or raised their hands to contest this false assertion and make clear that we unequivocally oppose Israel’s oppression of Palestinians.
- This is also true on college and university campuses. Challenging Hillel and Chabad’s claims to institutional monopoly over Jewish life on campus is done best by building strong alternative anti-Zionist communal spaces and offering anti-Zionist rituals, at the same time as directly confronting their use of Jewish identity to hold back progressive policy on Palestine at the university. For example, students have protested a Hillel recruitment event while also raising awareness for incoming freshmen about Jewish alternatives on campus.
- Advancing long-term, focused and strategic campaigns against AIPAC and the ADL.
- As detailed in the campaigns section (see page X), JVP is prioritizing long-term campaigns targeting the relationships between members of Congress and AIPAC, as well as taking on the ADL’s investment arm JLens. Both of these campaigns leverage the strength of JVP and the broader movement against specific anti-democratic and dangerous roles that these organizations are playing.
We will interrupt and intervene in the sales of Palestinian land to aspiring Jewish settlers from the U.S. and shift the narrative around these land sales. Events supporting the theft and sale of Palestinian land, in full violation of international law, are taking place around the country — and they’re increasingly being held in synagogues and other Jewish communal spaces. This is a strategy to make the media story about the protests outside synagogues rather than the land theft itself. As these land sales have expanded, the opposition has succeeded in their media strategy, and now those narratives about the proliferation of protests at synagogues are being used against the Palestine movement in policy fights and being inserted into mainstream narratives about Palestine as a way to demonize the movement and try to claw back lost ground. It’s critical that JVP deepen our interventions against these land sales to try to both stop them and intervene in the media narrative, with an awareness that this requires a proactive strategy and great delicacy to do well.
Tactics may include:
- Public education and media work about the land sales and stories of the families whose land and homes are being stolen
- Coalition effort with other Jewish left groups
- House of worship pledge campaign, with rabbi-to-rabbi organizing
- Communal organizing inside institutions holding land sales
- Example: The JVP Rabbinical Council wrote a powerful statement condemning the sale of Palestinian land in synagogues, intervening by providing public moral leadership that could be cited where needed in media and policy work.