Appendix: Resilience Framework & Assessment Tool
5 min read
- View as Markdown Open this page as plain Markdown (opens in a new tab)
- Open in ChatGPT Ask questions about this page (opens in a new tab)
- Open in Claude Ask questions about this page (opens in a new tab)
- Open in Google AI Studio Ask questions about this page (Google account required) (opens in a new tab)
Resilience defined #
- The capacity to stay connected to ourselves and each other includes being able to stay in relationship with one another, and to access our feelings, aliveness, grief, joy
- The capacity to adapt means we are able to transform, make choices, stay in motion and evolve as needed
- The capacity to remain protagonistic includes being able to see possibilities, to feel agency, and to stay focused on a positive vision for future
- The capacity to make meaning means that we are able to understand our circumstances and connect our responses to the purpose and mission of our work
Many of us gravitate toward one component and struggle with another. Similar to a switchboard with multiple dials, under conditions of stress, we may “turn down” in one area while maintaining strength or turning up the volume in another. Under stress, some of us may be wired to seek connection over a shared sense of powerlessness. Others may pull away from a group while feeling “I can do this alone.” Below, each category is broken out to illustrate where you individually or collectively may struggle with certain components of resilience, and some antidotes.
These categories contain considerable overlap and are in relationship to one another. For example, the ability to be experimental is a component of both adaptability and protagonism. The ability to listen deeply and reflect back on someone else’s experience is a component of connection and meaning-making. Think of these less as rigid categories, and more prompts for reflection about where you or your formation have been struggling, or can grow.
Orienting to resilience as a collective practice #
We are orienting to resilience as a collective practice, something embedded in “how” we do the work as much as something to support recovery.
Indicators of lack of connection #
- Desire to pull away from the group or not share what you are feeling with others.
- Dissociation from emotions and bodily sensations.
- Desire to skip the relational component of meeting, stick to “strictly business.”
- Not having a sense of what is going on in the lives of the people around you (other comrades, neighbors, etc).
- Fear of vulnerability, meetings or spaces not having the psychological safety required for vulnerability.
- Lack of ability to listen deeply to others or empathize.
- Inability to be present with, or hold others’ or one’s own grief.
Ways to build connection #
- Sharing feelings with others, creating containers to talk explicitly about our emotions in organizing spaces.
- Journaling and / or external processing.
- Building relational connections into every meeting.
- Building in practices to stay connected to the body (exercise, walking, stretching).
- Retreats that exist just for team-building or rest.
- Practices for repair or rituals of connection after a big disagreement.
- Building rituals to hold and honor grief.
Indicators of lack of adaptability #
- Feeling “stuck” in patterns that are not working but unable to change them.
- Letting fear of change guide decision-making.
- Inability to “let go,” or a rigidness / brittle shape.
- Lack of flexibility around time, un-grounded urgency, lack of understanding that things sometimes take longer than expected.
- Inability to tolerate uncertainty.
- Lack of ability to solve problems creatively / out of the box.
Ways to build adaptability #
- Individual or group meditation, being with what is.
- Strengthening your digital security and/or doing safety planning for yourself and loved ones.
- Active listening to people you disagree with to see new solutions.
- Increasing flexibility with time, allowing things to take longer.
- Trying a new practice as a group or individual.
- Scenario-planning at the beginning of a project.
- Building in opportunities to evaluate our work and giving space to how we may need to shift or change.
Indicators of lack of protagonism #
- Deep cynicism, feeling of “nothing is going to change” or “effort is futile.”
- A sense of not having any choice, deep powerlessness, or only being a victim of conditions with no agency.
- Lack of ability to be experimental, or feel empowered to be experimental.
- Inability to see the long arc, to remember past victories, to see oneself as an actor that can change history.
- Sense of there being nothing new, “we’ve seen this all before,” there are no possibilities for action.
- Inability to see or develop the leadership of other people.
Ways to build protagonism #
- Grounding in the past – movement elders, family, ancestors, reminding us that we’re never starting from zero.
- In difficult crisis situations, doing a group exercise on locus of control / where we have agency.
- Experimentation, deliberately trying something you’ve never tried before.
- Reading Sci-Fi!
- Reading about movements from other countries under similar conditions.
- Developing others’ leadership, and structures/systems, so the work continues and expands beyond you.
- Writing down the things you’re proud of.
Indicators of lack of meaning-making #
- Inability to see one’s role in something larger, a greater sense of the world, of a longer story.
- No or few opportunities for real feedback, or a lack of culture of feedback.
- Lack of political education or sense of history, no ability to see continuity / change over time in struggle.
- Lack of connection to elders who have been in struggle longer and can share lessons.
- No culture of study to apply theory or frameworks to current conditions.
- Lack of ability to debrief after a major action or campaign, or lack of ability to provide feedback on someone’s leadership.
- Lack of an orientation to political development as a collective process.
Ways to build meaning-making #
- Reading: history, poetry, fiction, theory.
- Being in connection and continuity with elders and people who have been in struggle for longer than we have.
- Understanding history to understand the present, political theory and praxis, frameworks and concepts to hold the chaotic awful world we are living in.
- Assess someone’s leadership using a rubric and reflection.
- Thinking about recent wins that wouldn’t have felt possible years ago.
- “Handshake between meaning & mystery.”
- Telling the story of our action– cynicism is when you lock in and believe that there’s no capacity to be surprised.
- What victories give us is that we can’t even imagine the full scope of our actions.
- Thinking on the scale of multiple generation life cycles.