Appendix: Filters
16 min read
- View as Markdown Open this page as plain Markdown (opens in a new tab)
- Open in ChatGPT Ask questions about this page (opens in a new tab)
- Open in Claude Ask questions about this page (opens in a new tab)
- Open in Google AI Studio Ask questions about this page (Google account required) (opens in a new tab)
Below is an appendix of strategic filters for decision-making.
Campaign filters #
- Does it help fulfill our mandate as a Jewish anti-Zionist organization based in the U.S.?
- Does it push one of our priority targets in the political, financial or cultural pillars?
- Does the story of the campaign, the target or the strategies within the campaign address more than one of the pillars? Are there ways this can weaken financial and political ties, for instance?
- Is there a pathway to win? Are there winnable, achievable goals that we can meet along the way? Will it help us build or shift power?
- Does the win include a pathway to have an actual impact?
- Does the campaign help us accomplish broader narrative or movement goals? Does the campaign tell a helpful, clear story that moves people to action or educates them on the systems upholding injustice?
- Does the campaign present opportunities to base-build?
- Does it present a potential to grow the movement through new coalition-building or relationships?
- Does it correspond with the political conditions at the moment? Does it make connections that weave our movements together or make impact for multiple struggles at once? Does it respond to current emergences in public mobilization or attention?
- Does it make sense for the local power map? Does it leverage the strength of movement against weaknesses in our opposition? What is the terrain of the fight (e.g., city council, local Jewish institution, school board, campus administration, school referendum) and what does that leverage of the coalition’s strength and connection?
Mobilizing filters #
When do we protest? #
This next section offers filters for different kinds of protests and mobilizations prioritized by JVP, as the 501(c)(4) organization, under this current set of political circumstances. Protest is a powerful tool of movements, and it is just one among many. The following categories are those where we believe JVP can most effectively and strategically mobilize:
- Major actions that prioritize media attention and narrative shift
- Public protests that prioritize base-building
- Actions that prioritize escalating pressure within a strategic campaign
- Participation in mass public anti-authoritarian protests
Major action that prioritizes media attention and narrative shift: JVP-led actions of substantial size with the primary goal of getting into the headlines to shift the narrative, and where the scale, tactics and conditions make meeting that goal likely. Such an action must meet specific criteria and be approved by the national organization. Examples:
- JVP sit-in at the Cannon House Rotunda on Capitol Hill
- On October 18, 2023, JVP organized 5,000 people from around the country to rally in Washington D.C., on a Wednesday, the first day Congress was back in session, with speakers including Stefanie Fox, Rep. Rashida Tlaib, Rep. Cori Bush, Naomi Klein and Mo Amer. 500 people then staged a protest in the Cannon Office Building on Capitol Hill to demand an immediate ceasefire in Palestine, with rabbis leading the crowd in chants and song. The action was live-streamed on mainstream news and made headlines around the world, including the front page of multiple outlets, helping to popularize the demand of “ceasefire.”
- JVP-NYC sit-in at Grand Central Station
- On October 27, 2023, on the same day that Israel first shut off electricity in Gaza, thousands of Jews and community members held a historic sit-in that shut down all of Grand Central Station, one of the world’s 10 most visited tourist attractions. By the end of the demonstration, #CeasefireNow had surpassed the World Series on X and was trending at #1. The demonstration garnered over 100 press stories and made the top headline of the New York Times. A wave of large train station protests followed suit all around the world —- JVP-Philadelphia brought together hundreds in Philadelphia, JVP-Chicago and chapters/pods across the Midwest led a major regional demonstration in Chicago and international groups shut down stations from London to Oslo to Dublin.
- JVP-LA sit-in at major Hollywood intersection
- In November 2023, JVP-LA mobilized over 1,000 Jews and allies to rally at the intersection of Hollywood Boulevard and Highland Avenue, the center of tourism and entertainment culture in Los Angeles, with a clear demand: Ceasefire Now. Joined by partners, including workers in entertainment and media, the action forced the demand into the public spotlight with bold and creative visuals. Major outlets covered the protest, and the next day the LA Times Editorial Board called for a ceasefire.
- Protest at Texas JNF Conference by JVP chapters + pods across the South
- In November 2024, members from JVP Southern chapters & pods — Dallas Fort-Worth, Houston, San Antonio, New Orleans and Charlotte — protested the Jewish National Fund’s (JNF) annual Global Conference for Israel, which was held in Dallas that year. Moments before the conference began, JVP members gathered at the street leading to the venue by symbolically “planting” an olive tree prop in hundreds of pounds of soil they dumped onto the road, using Jewish symbols and songs to condemn the JNF’s cynical use of tree planting as a weapon of ethnic cleansing. The protest garnered coverage in local traditional media and undermined the JNF’s attempt to speak for the Jewish community, clearing the way for several days of Palestinian-led protest.
Public protest that prioritizes base-building: JVP-led public protest that aims to express public opposition to a development, visibilize anti-Zionist Jewish voices, welcome in new people and sustain or grow anti-Zionist Jewish community. Examples:
- JVP-Western Mass 25 mile march
- In December 2023, JVP-Western Mass co-organized a 25 mile march — the length of Gaza — in solidarity with Palestinians who have been forced from their homes, starved, bombed and killed by the Israeli military with the U.S. government’s backing. As constituents of Senators Warren and Markey, they marched from Northampton to the Senators’ Springfield office door, demanding they call for a permanent ceasefire, an end to the siege of Gaza, an end to the genocide of the Palestinian people and an end to U.S.-backed weapon sales to Israel.
- JVP-South Florida protests at Art Basel festival
- Every December since 2023, JVP-South Florida and partners have organized a protest at Art Basel, a major art festival that has people coming from all over the world, using signs, leaflets and brochures that described the ongoing genocide, called for an end to U.S. and Miami Beach complicity in genocide and shared examples of Palestinian art and artists.
- JVP-Indiana fast for Gaza
- JVP-Indiana held a rotating fast for Gaza from August through November 2025, with 80 people across the state. They used the tactic to bring broader public attention to the horrors unfolding in Gaza, publicizing through banner drops and public ritual and mobilizing a wider set of people to write to elected officials.
- Public seders and Shabbats at student encampments
- Jewish students, including JVP student chapters in many locations, held public seders, Shabbats and Havdalahs during the historic student encampments of Spring 2024. These visibilized the many Jewish students participating in and leading the encampment movement to protest the genocide, intervening in the face of weaponized claims of antisemitism while also building and growing communities of anti-Zionist Jews in the student movement.
- JVP-Kansas City Tashlich Ritual Ceremony
- During the High Holy Days in 2025, JVP-KC held a massive public Tashlich ritual to bring in more leaders and put public pressure on Rep. Emmauel Cleaver to support the Block the Bombs Act. More than 80 community members dressed in white and cast off sins in the river through ritual. Several leaders developed skills in recruitment, turnout and ritual and song.
Action that prioritizes escalating pressure within a strategic campaign: Actions whose purpose is to enhance pressure against a specific target as part of a strategic local campaign to force them to move closer to giving in to the campaign demand. This could be opportunistic, taking advantage of a development that’s in the headlines, or it could be a planned escalation. Tactics should be designed in direct relationship to that goal. Examples:
- JVP-Triangle, JVP-Charlotte and Break the Bonds NC coalition demonstration at State Treasurer’s office as part of their Break the Bonds campaign
- The Break the Bonds NC coalition – including JVP Asheville, PalYouthNC, Muslims for Social Justice, and public school workers – built out a series of actions (meeting with the Treasurer, gathering petition signatures, pursuing union endorsements, etc.) with increasing escalation over the course of a six-month period calling on their State Treasurer to divest the state pension fund from Israel Bonds. These actions culminated in a rally and petition delivery of almost 5,000 signatures to the Treasurer’s office by 35 state workers and union members as well as community organizers from some of the 35+ endorsing organizations supporting the campaign.
- Action escalating Evict Elbit campaign with JVP-Atlanta and coalition
- JVP-Atlanta volunteers, in deep partnership with Weelaunee Coalition, staged an Occupy Newmark action celebrating Chanukah’s anti-colonial resistance and escalating ongoing protest against Israel’s occupation of Palestine, specifically the use of Elbit’s tools of mass destruction in the U.S.-Israel genocide in Gaza and in the large-scale violence, displacement and killings in the West Bank. After many months of protesting Elbit’s surveillance and weapons systems and the complicity of Newmark Real Estate in leasing to Elbit’s subsidiary Universal Avionics, they decided to create a stronger presence within the Newmark building, primarily as a strategic move to 1) bring more attention to the issue, 2) apply greater pressure to the site’s infrastructure via its security protocol and keeping them off balance regarding our next move and 3) advance toward the goal of evicting Elbit from Georgia.
- Mobilizations at congressional offices to build pressure towards endorsing Block the Bombs legislation and/or voting for Joint Resolutions of Disapproval (JRDs) to block weapons
- JVP-Philadelphia has organized repeated protests over time to build pressure on Senator Fetterman and expose his votes against the JRDs and for more funding for war in Israel and Iran. Fetterman is staunchly Zionist and unlikely to shift, so these actions provide an opportunity to demonstrate loudly and visibly how unpopular his positions are, to remind the broader public of how unaccountable he is and to serve as a warning to other electeds. These actions have included large protests at his office, creative visuals and a phone zap, where JVP members called his office every 5 minutes for a full day demanding he vote to stop funding arms for Israel. Some of the rallies outside his office included giant red phone props and the “speakers” at the rally made actual calls to Fetterman’s office that were broadcast to the crowd, where they spoke from the heart about why he needs to stop funding war.
- JVP-DC Metro has built pressure on Virginia Senator Warner with a variety of tactics. In April 2026, on the same day that JVP members met with his staff asking if he would finally vote for the JRDs, JVP members also effectively bird-dogged Warner at an event, asking him face-to-face on video how he would vote and pushing him to stop funding genocide. One week later, he voted yes on the JRDs for the first time since the genocide began.
- JVP-Chicago leaders led an 18-day hunger strike that included repeated actions outside of the offices of Illinois Senators Dick Durbin and Tammy Duckworth demanding that Congress stop arming Israel and stop starving Gaza. They launched the Hunger Strike with Rep. Delia Ramirez, who introduced the Block the Bombs Act in Congress, and the strike became a successful vehicle to secure meetings with congresspeople from across the Chicago area, securing new co-sponsors for the bill. It culminated in an escalated action targeting Sen. Duckworth, who had never voted for a JRD. Since this action, the Senator has supported every JRD introduced as of the release of this plan.
- JVP-Seattle Palantir action to launch statewide divestment campaign
- In July 2025 as part of a coalitional “Cut Ties” divestment campaign, JVP Seattle organized over 100 Jews and allies to put an end to business as usual for Palantir. This action brought awareness to the Seattle public that Washington State invests over $73 million in Palantir, that they have an office in the city and that Palantir fuels human rights violations in the United States and in Palestine.
- Occidental College encampment to escalate a divestment campaign
- At Occidental College, students in April 2025 launched the second longest encampment since Spring 2024, following their Board of Directors’ refusal to consider a divestment proposal. Students drew powerful connections between anti-ICE struggles, the war on Iran and the ongoing genocide at Gaza while demanding their college live up to its stated values, rather than use its student tuition dollars to profit off genocide and apartheid. The action garnered significant local press in the LA area.
Mass public anti-authoritarian protest: Increasingly, as fascism rises in the U.S., there will be moments where masses are asked to pour out for specific protests that demonstrate a united front against fascism. JVP commits to participating in these actions where a broad front flexes power, which may include acting alongside organizations and actors with which we have significant political disagreements. Examples:
- Mass actions including No Kings Day, May Day, the 250th anniversary of the U.S., Labor Day, a mass mobilization around the time of the mid-term elections. JVP chapters and pods bring JVP messaging through speaking, tabling, wearing JVP T-shirts and bringing specific signage.
- There will also be countless mass actions that are not pre-planned and rather respond to a crisis moment or uprising energy. For example, such rapid response actions for the masses may include demonstrations against: U.S. aggression or war against another country (i.e., Palestine, Iran, Venezuela, Cuba, Colombia, Greenland, etc); ICE, the deportation machine and the invocation of the Insurrection Act; cuts to social services; threats to trans people and bodily autonomy; or the stealing of elections. In these cases, JVP encourages chapters, pods and the broader membership to show up to these actions, wear our T-shirts and bring our messaging around Palestine into the current moment.
How do we protest? #
When we protest, actions should be planned for maximum effectiveness and rigor, with impact, capacity and risk in mind. Filters for action:
- Impact – Any action or protest should meet at least one of the below criteria:
- Does it advance an existing JVP local or national campaign with material impact, by building pressure against primary or secondary campaign targets?
- Does it contribute to the broad anti-authoritarian front through visible Jewish pro-Palestine participation, and/or by offering numbers and organization at crucial moments of mass mobilizing?
- Does it shift the narrative at a major scale by getting Palestine and movement demands in large media outlets? And is there a realistic media assessment for why mainstream media would engage (i.e., is it responding to major events currently getting media attention or featuring high profile people)?
- Capacity towards impact:
- Timeline: What’s a realistic timeline for a strategic action according to the intended impact and goals? Especially important for narrative-focused rapid response actions.
- Numbers: How many people can be turned out in that timeline, including for different key and higher-skill or higher-risk roles, and would that be sufficient for the intended impact and goals?
- Skill, relationships and systems: Has the group done this before? Do the current skillsets and/or systems exist to make it happen, and/or can they be built intentionally in time for the proposed action?
- Media: In a moment like this, national communications staff will support media strategy, but media goals can be reached only if the local chapter or pod also has media skills, capacity and pre-existing journalist relationships.
- Are the local media and communications plans already skills in place and/or can they be built intentionally in time for the proposed action?
- Are there local media relationships that can be leveraged?
- Are there trained spokespeople?
- Does the chapter or pod have an active social media presence and a skilled-up member social media team?
- Risk and Process:
- Does the action involve any legal risk to individuals or the organization? If so, the action must be coordinated with and approved by the national organization in order to minimize those risks.
- Does the action involve national campaigns and/or congressional or federally elected officials? If so, the action must be coordinated with and approved by the national organization.
Fighting the Right filters #
When considering a campaign, mobilization, statement or rapid response approach to a development in the fight against fascism in the U.S., we will ask:
- As always: will JVP participation or response advance the struggle for Palestinian liberation, particularly toward our long-term goals?
- Does it contribute to the fight against the consolidation of power by the current, far-right authoritarian regime?
- Does it build the broader Left, and/or position the Left to assert leadership over the broad anti-authoritarian front?
- Does JVP have a specific role and contribution to offer based on either or both of the following filters?
- 1) As a Jewish anti-Zionist organization
- For example, intervening against weaponized antisemitism
- 2) As a large base-building organization, based on geography, people power, structure and/or skills
- For example, where there are local relationships, where sheer numbers matter or where JVP chapters can use existing infrastructure, skills or relationships to show up for a local fight or emergent rapid response
- 1) As a Jewish anti-Zionist organization
Repression and resilience filters for decision-making #
Maintaining core values and relationships:
- Can this form of protection be done in a way that creates templates, possibilities, support for or protection for other organizations in the movement?
- Does this form of protection allow us to maintain trust, internally and externally, in a climate that will pit organizations against each other?
Maintaining impact:
- Does this allow us to continue building and mobilizing local grassroots power toward our political goals?
- Does this allow us to continue offering a counterweight to Jewish Zionist organizations politically, culturally, narratively or materially?
- Does this allow us to advance campaigns with material political or financial impact?
- Does this allow us to continue defending and protecting our partner organizations and their organizing?
Maintaining grassroots power:
- Does this allow us to maintain JVP’s people power?
- Does this allow us to continue communicating with and maintaining trust of partner organizations?
- Does this allow us to continue communicating to the broad public via media and social media?
Maintaining infrastructure and safety:
- Does this allow us to maintain a legal, compliant and digitally secure operational and financial structure?
- Does this minimize personal liability and/or physical, legal or financial risk for individual staff members, member leaders, board members and donors, as well as their families?