A national Christian group founded to support Israel
held an event in that nation's honor Sunday night in Madison, drawing protesters
who argue the group is taking advantage of Jewish people and aims to hasten the
apocalypse.
But David Brog, executive director of Christians United for Israel, who came
to speak Sunday at "An Evening to Honor Israel," said he is surprised by the
level of misunderstanding his organization generates, especially in places such
as Madison and Berkeley, Calif.
"There is mistrust of conservative Christians, especially in places where
there are a lot of liberal activists who jump to conclusions and don't have open
minds," he said.
About 50 people, including many members of Madison's chapter of Jewish Voice
for Peace, met Sunday evening outside the Overture Center with signs and fliers
protesting the event and the theology of Christian Zionism, which supports the
return of Jewish people to the so-called Holy Land.
Haley Pollack of Madison's Jewish Voice for Peace, a national group that
advocates a U.S. Middle East policy based on democracy and human rights, said
its members are concerned CUI is trying to hasten the Armageddon prophesied in
the Bible by restoring Jewish people to Israel. She said CUI members believe
that would lead to the second coming of Christ.
"I think that's an exploitation of the Jewish community," Pollack said,
adding her group is worried because CUI "has real holds in government and
foreign policy. They're dragging the United States government into never-ending
violence."
Lenny Kanter said Christian Zionists have taken advantage of the Jewish
people to further a "bizarre fantasy" of the apocalypse. "That's no support for
Jewish people," he said.
Brog called those allegations "inaccurate, a complete fantasy." But he notes
that John Hagee, the Texas pastor who founded the fast-growing group about a
year ago, believes historical and political justifications, in addition to the
"land deed from God," bolster Israel's claims on the Holy Land.
Another complaint about CUI is that it dismisses the potential for peace
negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians. This troubles Bonnie Block,
whose sign advocated for peace in both Israel and Iraq. As a Christian, Block
said she finds it easy to unite with Jewish people, but was worried about CUI
making "extreme" religious connections and claims.
"It is religious fundamentalists of any religion that are a problem," she
said.
But Brog said CUI "sees no point in trading land for peace, when the
Palestinians say Israel has no right to exist."
"It is true that we are interested in the end-times prophesies in the Bible,"
Brog said. "We do expect a great conflagration, a great war. But it doesn't
affect our political activity. We want peace."
One reason CUI is holding meetings to support Israel in cities nationwide is
to mobilize pressure on Congress and the Bush administration in matters
pertaining to Israel.
Joel Kitsemble, pastor of Spirit of Faith Church in Madison and director of
Wisconsin's CUI, helped coordinate bringing CUI to Madison. Kitsemble said the
event - which included prayer, music, fundraising and speakers including Brog,
Barukh Binah, consul general of Israel to the Midwest, and Billye Brim, who has
studied Biblical prophecy - was held to "break down walls of separation between
Christians and Jews."