Palestinian Quilt Presents a Different Viewpoint
Creation of Israel Came At Great Cost, Some Say
By Sylvia Moreno
Washington Post Staff Writer
Sunday, May 18, 2008; C05
One
man grasped a large key close to his chest as a symbol of the compound
his family was forced to flee 60 years ago. Another flipped through the
pages of a tiny clothbound diary, stamped 1948. In it, his father
meticulously noted the events occurring in Palestine: "A cloudy day.
Critical situation . . . and all the people leaving the country."
These men and dozens of other Palestinians and Palestinian Americans who gathered on the Mall yesterday call the events of 1948 the nakba ,
the Arab word for catastrophe. Their event was organized as a
counterpoint to the 60th anniversary of the creation of Israel,
celebrated nationally and in Israel last week, where President Bush joined in the ceremony.
To
make way for Israel, 750,000 Palestinians were expelled from their
homes and more than 400 of their villages were destroyed, organizers of
the event said.
"While people are welcome to celebrate the
creation of Israel, it's significant and important for people to
understand that in order for Israel to be created, the Palestinians
paid a price for what happened," said Nora Hasan, a member of the
Washington Interfaith Alliance
for Middle East Peace. The event also was sponsored by Sharing
Jerusalem, the Vineeta Foundation, the American Palestinian Women's
Association and the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee.
The
group gathered west of the reflecting pool, in view of the Capitol. The
event was one of many held in more than 20 cities nationwide. Here, the
group laid out a huge antique quilt, each square stitched with the name
of a Palestinian village, the number of residents and the year it was
destroyed.
A large map of Palestine was outlined on the lawn with a rope and dotted with flags that represented the villages.
The
names of the villages were read as a bell tolled, and eyewitnesses, or
the children of eyewitnesses, spoke about what happened in 1948.
"My
mother walked into my room early in the morning and said, 'Get up,
we're going to Lebanon,' " recalled George Hishmeh, now a freelance
columnist and a member of the Washington Association of Arab
Journalists, whose family experienced the exodus from Haifa, a port on
the Mediterranean Sea, 60 years ago this month.
Family
members packed 11 suitcases and left aboard a ship for what they
thought would be a vacation for a couple of months. "We thought we
would come back," Hishmeh said, stopping to wipe away tears.
Philip
Farah, 56, of Vienna, carried his father's diary from 1948, which
contains the story of how the family had to leave West Jerusalem. And
Yusif Farsakh, 81, of Arlington, had the large key that his grandfather
and father used to unlock the compound in Birzeit, north of Jerusalem,
where the family lived for generations.
Such keys are handed down
through families today, he and other event organizers said, to
symbolize the right of return to Palestine. "Not the right of return in
the sense of kicking people out of their homes, but the right to a
claim," said Mark Braverman of Bethesda, a member of Jewish Voice for
Peace, which supports the Washington Interfaith Alliance for Middle
East Peace.
"It's like America acknowledging slavery and
apologizing, or acknowledging to the Native Americans that we took
their land," Braverman said. "There needs to be an acknowledgment by
Israel that 'we took your land; now let's talk and move forward.' There
needs to be an acknowledgment that there was a people and culture that
was destroyed."